61 Highlights 43 Differences 6 Reactions 0 Likes

Casper The One vs Sleep Innovations Shiloh: 61 Highlights & 43 Differences — So, Which Mattress Actually Works Better

Get insight on cost-effectiveness and quality in these popular mattress models. We’ve laid out how Casper The One and Sleep Innovations Shiloh differ on paper and in practice — especially when it comes to flippable design, adjustable base compatibility, split mattress option & replaceable comfort layer program and actual sleep support.

76 Points
Casper The One
28 Points
Sleep Innovations
Sleep Innovations
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
vs

Highlights 217

No extras. Just what matters.
76 Points
vs
28 Points

Why is Casper The One better than Sleep Innovations Shiloh ?

Scroll down for more facts

Casper The One vs Sleep Innovations Shiloh: A Detailed Mattress Showdown

When choosing between the Casper The One foam mattress and the Sleep Innovations Shiloh hybrid mattress, buyers find two high-quality options with notable differences. Both models aim to deliver restful sleep backed by a 10-year limited warranty and free return policies, but they diverge significantly in construction, firmness, and comfort adjustability. Casper The One provides a medium-firm 7/10 firmness scale rating with zoned memory foam layers designed to support heavier sleepers and couples, whereas Sleep Innovations Shiloh offers a notably firmer 9/10 rating featuring a plush foam comfort layer over Bonnell coils to cater to those who prefer a sturdier and pillow-top feel.

Health and safety certifications also distinguish these models. Casper holds CertiPUR-US certification with low VOC emissions and a chemical-free fire barrier but lacks formaldehyde-free and OEKO-TEX certifications. In contrast, Shiloh excels with formaldehyde-free content, OEKO-TEX certification, and anti-microbial treatments for enhanced hygiene, appealing to users prioritizing organic and health-conscious materials. Both mattresses feature breathable covers, but only Shiloh includes moisture-wicking fabric and has a superior heat dissipation rating.

Why Casper The One Excels In Comfort And Versatility

Casper The One stands out especially for its thoughtfully designed foam core and multiple comfort layers that include memory foam and polyfoam. This combination creates a balanced medium firmness with zoned support that tailors cushioning to different body zones, providing exceptional spinal alignment and pressure relief. Additionally, it supports split mattress options, which is a significant advantage for couples with differing sleep preferences. The mattress is vacuum-sealed for portability and boasts an impressive one-hour quick expansion time after unboxing, making setup hassle-free.

Heavy sleeper support is an important feature here, as Casper The One's medium firmness and durable foam core are built to accommodate higher weight capacities without sacrificing comfort or durability. Although Casper does not include adjustable base compatibility, its medium feel is generally versatile and couples will appreciate its couple-friendly design, which helps minimize motion transfer and improve sleep quality.

The Unique Strengths Of Sleep Innovations Shiloh's Hybrid Build

Sleep Innovations Shiloh offers a different appeal for those who prefer a firm mattress with a traditional hybrid feel. Its core feature is a sturdy foam base layered over a Bonnell coil system that delivers robust support and bounce not typical of all-foam mattresses. The plush memory foam comfort layer together with a luxurious pillow top quilted organic cotton cover enhances softness while providing excellent durability and air circulation.

Hygiene-conscious sleepers will appreciate the mattress's anti-microbial treatment and formaldehyde- and OEKO-TEX certifications, ensuring a safer and cleaner sleep surface. Plus, it supports adjustable bed bases, expanding flexibility for those with specific comfort needs.

However, the Shiloh is less suitable for heavier individuals as it lacks heavy sleeper support and has a weight limit of 350 lbs. Its unpacking process is also less convenient, requiring up to 24 hours to fully expand versus Casper's one hour. Meanwhile, Shiloh's lack of a split mattress option limits customization options for couples.

Quick Take

Casper The One is a versatile foam mattress balancing medium firmness with zoned support, quick setup, and split options ideal for diverse sleepers, including heavy individuals and couples. Sleep Innovations Shiloh provides a firmer, more traditional hybrid experience with organic fabrics, enhanced hygiene features, and adjustable base compatibility ; perfect for buyers prioritizing health-conscious materials and a sturdy feel.

Bottom Line: Which Mattress Should You Choose?

For those seeking a mattress that combines modern foam comfort, versatile sizing options like split configurations, and robust support for heavier bodies at an accessible price, $599 at Casper.com offers outstanding value. Its certifications and quick expansion further elevate its appeal.

In contrast, if your priorities include a firmer hybrid mattress with premium organic materials, anti-microbial protection, and adjustable base compatibility ; and you can accept a higher price and longer setup time ; Sleep Innovations Shiloh remains a reliable choice despite fewer customization options.

Verdict

  • Winner: Casper The One - Offers versatile, medium-firm zoned foam comfort with split mattress sizing, heavy sleeper support, and quick setup, all at a competitive price and strong safety certifications.
  • Runner-up: Sleep Innovations Shiloh - Delivers a firm and plush hybrid experience with organic materials and enhanced hygiene; excellent for those needing adjustable base compatibility but less suited for heavier sleepers or those needing split options.

Comparisons 14

Two enter. One leaves your cart.

Price comparisons

(✱) Prices may be changed at any time without further notice.

Related comparisons 14

Because one duel is never enough.

Comparisons & Facts 217

Side by side. The numbers. The features. No drama.

Is Casper The One better than Sleep Innovations Shiloh for your sleep needs? This mattresses guide compares all the right angles so you can rest easy with your choice.

General Information 11

Product Type

What type of mattress is it?

69 Casper The One 0 Votes Memory Foam

66 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Memory Foam

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

The product type is memory foam, providing adaptable support and comfort through viscoelastic technology.

Defines the fundamental mattress category.

Warranty Period

What is the warranty period?

59 Casper The One 0 Votes 10 Years

56 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes 10 Years

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Warranty Period

Both Casper The One and Sleep Innovations Shiloh provide a 10-year warranty period, offering long-term protection against defects. This equal warranty period ensures reliability for customers choosing either mattress.

Duration of warranty coverage.

Mattress Type

What is the mattress type?

69 Casper The One 0 Votes Foam

76 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Memory Foam

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Mattress Type

Casper The One utilizes foam as its mattress type, while Sleep Innovations Shiloh is specifically memory foam. Customers seeking advanced memory foam technology might prefer Sleep Innovations Shiloh for its targeted construction.

Categorizes construction type.

Trial Period Length

What is the trial period length?

100 Nights 0 Votes
Casper The One
100 Nights 0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Trial Period Length

Casper The One and Sleep Innovations Shiloh both offer a generous 100-night trial period. This equal trial length provides ample time to test comfort, making either mattress a comfortable risk-free choice.

Indicates how many nights consumers can try the mattress risk-free.

Model Name

What is the model name?

58 Casper The One 0 Votes The One

77 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Shiloh

Provides the marketing name used by the brand.

Model Number

What is the model number?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Unique identifier used internally or for warranty claims.

Release Year

What is the release year?

99 Casper The One 0 Votes 2024

79 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes 2021

Indicates when the product was introduced to the market.

Country of Manufacture

Where is the mattress manufactured?

99 Casper The One 0 Votes USA

96 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes USA

Shows where the mattress is manufactured.

Intended Use

What is the intended use?

49 Casper The One 0 Votes Home

46 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Home

Defines the usage context.

Target Market

What is the target market?

97 Casper The One 0 Votes US, Global

96 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes US

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Target Market

Casper The One targets both the US and global markets, while Sleep Innovations Shiloh focuses only on the US. Casper The One is more suitable for buyers looking for wider availability internationally.

Specifies the geographic or demographic market.

Free Return Policy

Does it come with a free return policy?

Yes 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Free Return Policy

Both Casper The One and Sleep Innovations Shiloh offer a free return policy, ensuring customers can return the mattress without extra costs. This makes both options equally risk-free in terms of return convenience for buyers.

Shows whether the product allows hassle-free returns.

Dimensions & Weight 110

Width (RV)

What is the mattress width for RV?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh (Help us out by suggesting one!)

The overall width of the mattress, important for fitting specific bed frames or RV layouts.

Height (RV)

What is the height of RV mattress?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh (Help us out by suggesting one!)

The height or thickness of the mattress, affecting comfort and support.

Width (California King)

What is the Cal King mattress width?

72 inch 0 Votes
Casper The One
72 inch 0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

The width is 72 inch, which converts to 182.88 cm for the California King size, a standard width providing wide sleeping space.

Standard width for California King mattress.

Depth (California King)

What is the Cal King mattress length?

84 inch 0 Votes
Casper The One
84 inch 0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

The depth is specified as 84 inch which converts to 213.36 cm. This dimension corresponds to the length of a California King mattress, providing ample sleeping space.

Standard length for California King mattress.

Mattress Size

What is the mattress size?

94 Casper The One 0 Votes Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King, Split King

72 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Twin, Full, Queen, King, Cal King

Identifies the size for the mattress.

Width (Twin)

What is the Twin mattress width?

38 inch 0 Votes
Casper The One
38 inch 0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Standard width for Twin size mattress.

Width (Twin XL)

What is the Twin XL mattress width?

38 inch 0 Votes
Casper The One

Who knows? 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Standard width for Twin XL mattress.

Width (Full)

What is the Full mattress width?

53 inch 0 Votes
Casper The One
53 inch 0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Standard width for Full (Double) mattress.

Width (Queen)

What is the Queen mattress width?

60 inch 0 Votes
Casper The One
60 inch 0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Standard width for Queen size mattress.

Width (King)

What is the King mattress width?

76 inch 0 Votes
Casper The One
76 inch 0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Standard width for King size mattress.

Width (Split King)

What is the Split King mattress width?

76 inch 0 Votes
Casper The One

Who knows? 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Combined width of two Twin XL mattresses.

Width (Super King)

What is the width of the Super King mattress?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh (Help us out by suggesting one!)

The width of the mattress. A wider mattress offers more space.

Comfort & Firmness 13

Firmness Level

What is the firmness level?

49 Casper The One 0 Votes Medium

56 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Firm

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Firmness Level

Casper The One is rated medium firmness, while Sleep Innovations Shiloh is firm. Those who prefer a softer sleep surface will find Casper better, while firm mattress lovers may favor Sleep Innovations Shiloh.

Describes the general firmness category.

Firmness Scale Rating

What is the firmness rating?

63 Casper The One 1 Votes 7/10

85 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes 9/10

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Firmness Scale Rating

The firmness scale rating for Casper The One is 7/10, offering moderate softness compared to Sleep Innovations Shiloh's 9/10, which is significantly firmer. Casper The One suits those desiring balanced softness.

Numeric scale where 1 is softest and 10 is firmest.

I really appreciate that Casper The One has a medium firmness rating of 7 out of 10 which feels just right for me versus the firmer 9 out of 10 on the Sleep Innovations Shiloh.

See more

Temperature Regulation Feature

Does it have temperature regulation features?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
Casper The One

While the foam layers are breathable, the Casper One doesn’t feature active cooling technology.

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

The mattress includes temperature regulation features to maintain a comfortable sleeping climate.

Indicates if mattress is designed to maintain neutral sleep temperature.

Pressure Relief Rating

What is the pressure relief rating?

89 Casper The One 0 Votes Excellent

65 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Good

Casper The One
Casper The One

The Casper One’s zoned memory foam provides pressure relief by allowing areas like the shoulders to sink in, while maintaining firmer support for the hips and back.

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Pressure relief is rated as good, meaning the mattress effectively alleviates pressure points for comfort.

Rates how well the mattress relieves pressure points.

Adjustable Firmness Range

Does it have an adjustable firmness range?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

The mattress does not feature an adjustable firmness range for personalized softness or firmness.

Shows if firmness can be adjusted or customized.

Comfort Layer Thickness

What is the comfort layer thickness?

4 inch 0 Votes
Casper The One
3 inch 0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Comfort Layer Thickness

Casper The One has a comfort layer thickness of 4 inches, one inch thicker than Sleep Innovations Shiloh's 3 inches. This makes Casper more suitable for those looking for extra cushioning.

Thickness of the comfort layer on top.

Motion Isolation Rating

What is the motion isolation rating?

64 Casper The One 0 Votes 8/10

76 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes 8/10

Casper The One
Casper The One

Excellent motion isolation ensures that movement on one side of the bed won’t disturb a partner, making it a great choice for couples.

Measures how well the mattress prevents motion transfer.

Cooling Technology

What cooling technology is included?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

51 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Bamboo, Open Cell Foam

GDescribes specific cooling methods used.

Ergonomic Certification

Does it have ergonomic certifications?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

83 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Ergocert

Lists recognized ergonomic approvals.

Comfort Technology

What comfort technology is included?

68 Casper The One 0 Votes Memory Foam

65 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Plush Foam

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Comfort Technology

Casper The One uses memory foam comfort technology, contrasting with the plush foam comfort technology in Sleep Innovations Shiloh. Casper The One suits those who prefer contouring support memory foam provides.

Special comfort features used in the top layers.

Zoned Support

Does the mattress include zoned support?

Yes 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Zoned Support

Casper The One offers zoned support, enhancing body alignment with targeted firmness zones. Sleep Innovations Shiloh lacks this feature. Casper The One is better for sleepers needing tailored spinal support.

Indicates if the mattress offers different support zones.

Edge Support Rating

What is the edge support rating?

79 Casper The One 0 Votes 8/10

66 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes 8/10

Indicates stability around the mattress edges.

Construction & Materials 16

Quilting Type

What quilting type is used?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

65 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Pillow Top

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Quilting Type

Quilting type is not available for Casper The One but Sleep Innovations Shiloh uses a pillow top quilting, adding extra softness. Shiloh is preferable for those who enjoy a plush surface.

Describes the quilting style on the mattress surface.

Cover Material

What is the cover material?

87 Casper The One 0 Votes Knit Fabric

56 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Organic Cotton

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Cover Material

Casper The One features a knit fabric cover, whereas Sleep Innovations Shiloh uses organic cotton. Sleep Innovations Shiloh's organic cotton cover may appeal more to customers seeking natural textiles.

Materials used for the outer cover.

Coil Type

What type of coil is used?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

46 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Bonnell

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Coil Type

Casper The One does not use coils, while Sleep Innovations Shiloh employs Bonnell coils. Shiloh might be better for customers preferring traditional coil support.

Identifies the coil construction used.

Comfort Layer Material

What is the comfort layer material?

90 Casper The One 0 Votes Memory Foam, Polyfoam

66 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Memory Foam

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Comfort Layer Material

Casper The One uses a mix of memory foam and polyfoam in its comfort layer, while Sleep Innovations Shiloh uses only memory foam. Casper may offer a balanced feel between support and softness.

Materials used in the comfort layers.

Flame Retardant Material

What flame retardant is used?

86 Casper The One 0 Votes Rayon

26 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Rayon

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Rayon is used as the flame retardant material, providing safety compliance while maintaining material comfort.

Material used to meet fire safety standards.

Natural / Organic Material

Does it use natural or organic materials?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

This product does not incorporate natural or organic materials in its construction.

Indicates whether natural or organic materials are included.

Hypoallergenic Treatment

Does it have hypoallergenic treatment?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

It includes hypoallergenic treatment to reduce the risk of allergic reactions from common allergens.

Shows if materials are treated to resist allergens.

Mattress Core Material

What is the core material?

89 Casper The One 0 Votes Foam

26 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Foam

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Mattress Core Material

Both Casper The One and Sleep Innovations Shiloh have foam mattress cores, providing consistent support and durability. This makes either mattress a solid foam-core choice.

Defines the main support structure.

Foam Type

What foam type is included?

90 Casper The One 0 Votes Memory Foam

61 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Memory Foam, High-Density

Specifies the type of foam used.

Coil Count

What is the coil count?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Number of coils in the mattress.

Coil Gauge

What is the coil gauge?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Thickness of the coils measured in gauge.

Layer Count

What is the layer count?

85 Casper The One 0 Votes 3

15 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes 3

Total number of layers in mattress construction.

Performance & Durability 11

Flippable Design

Can the mattress be flipped?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Flippable Design

Both Casper The One and Sleep Innovations Shiloh lack flippable designs, meaning the mattresses are single-sided. Buyers seeking flip capability won't find it in either option.

Shows whether the mattress can be flipped.

Expected Lifespan

What is the expected lifespan?

8 Years 0 Votes
Casper The One
7 Years 0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

The expected lifespan is 7 years, which is typical for memory foam mattresses before noticeable wear may occur.

Average years the mattress is designed to last.

Memory Foam Recovery Time

What is the recovery time of the foam?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

4 sec 0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

The memory foam has a recovery time of 4 seconds, indicating how quickly the foam regains shape after compression for good responsiveness.

Time it takes memory foam to return to shape.

Indentation Load Deflection (ILD)

What is the ILD value?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

66 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Medium (20–30 lbs)

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

The indentation load deflection rating is medium, equivalent to 20–30 lbs or approximately 9.07–13.61 kg, indicating moderate firmness and support.

Measures foam firmness by required load to indent.

Rotatable Design

Can the mattress be rotated?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Featuring a rotatable design, the mattress can be rotated to extend lifespan and maintain comfort by evening out wear.

Indicates if mattress can be rotated to extend life.

Warranty Coverage Type

What type of warranty coverage is provided?

87 Casper The One 0 Votes Limited

26 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Limited

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Warranty Coverage Type

Both mattresses have a limited warranty coverage type, offering similar levels of protection which makes them equally reliable in terms of warranty.

Describes the type of warranty coverage.

Anti-Microbial Treatment

Does it have antimicrobial treatment?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 1 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Anti-Microbial Treatment

Sleep Innovations Shiloh includes an anti-microbial treatment for added hygiene, while Casper The One does not. Shiloh is more suitable for users prioritizing antimicrobial protection.

Indicates if materials are treated to resist microbes.

I find the anti-microbial treatment on Sleep Innovations Shiloh important for hygiene although Casper The One lacks this feature.

See more

Sag Resistance Rating

What is the sag resistance rating?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

43 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Medium

Rates the mattress resistance to sagging.

Density Rating

What is the density rating?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

35 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Medium

Foam density that indicates durability and support.

Bed Bug Resistant

Is the mattress bed bug resistant?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Bed Bug Resistant

Neither Casper The One nor Sleep Innovations Shiloh is bed bug resistant. Neither mattress offers specific protection against bed bugs, which may be a concern for sensitive buyers.

Shows if the mattress has protection against bed bugs.

Indentation Resistance Guarantee

Is there an indentation resistance guarantee?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Indentation Resistance Guarantee

Indentation resistance guarantee is provided by Sleep Innovations Shiloh but not Casper The One. Shiloh offers better assurance against visible mattress sagging over time.

Assurance that mattress won’t indent prematurely.

Comfort Adjustability 9

Adjustable Base Compatibility

Is it compatible with adjustable bases?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 1 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Adjustable Base Compatibility

Sleep Innovations Shiloh supports adjustable base compatibility, unlike Casper The One. Shiloh is ideal for users wanting to use adjustable foundations.

Indicates if mattress can be used with an adjustable bed base.

Adjustable base compatibility on Sleep Innovations Shiloh is a feature I really need but unfortunately Casper The One doesn't support that.

See more

Split Mattress Option

Is it available in split design?

Yes 1 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Split Mattress Option

Casper The One supports a split mattress option, unlike Sleep Innovations Shiloh. Casper is better for users who want customizable firmness or easier moving.

Shows if mattress can be split into two sides.

Casper The One's split mattress option is a big plus for me so I can customize my side, something Sleep Innovations Shiloh doesn't offer at all.

See more

Replaceable Comfort Layer Program

Does it offer a replaceable comfort layer program?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Indicates if brand allows swapping comfort layers through a program.

Head & Foot Elevation Support

Does it support head & foot elevation?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

This mattress supports head and foot elevation, allowing users to adjust the inclination for comfort or medical needs.

Shows if mattress supports head and foot elevation.

Dual Firmness Option

Does it offer dual firmness?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Dual Firmness Option

Neither Casper The One nor Sleep Innovations Shiloh offers a dual firmness option. Both are single firmness mattresses so customization is limited.

Indicates if mattress offers two firmness levels in one design.

Removable Top Layer

Does it have a removable top layer?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Removable Top Layer

Neither mattress has a removable top layer, so cleaning or layer adjustments are not available with either Casper The One or Sleep Innovations Shiloh.

Indicates if the top comfort layer can be removed or swapped.

Modular Layer Design

Does it have modular layers?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Modular Layer Design

Modular layer design is not present in either Casper The One or Sleep Innovations Shiloh, so neither mattress allows for easy layer swapping.

Allows layers to be rearranged for customized comfort.

Customizable Firmness Inserts

Does it support firmness inserts?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Supports inserts or pads to adjust firmness.

Smart Adjustable Firmness

Does it offer smart firmness adjustment?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Indicates if firmness can be changed via smart tech.

Health & Safety 9

CertiPUR-US Certified

Is it CertiPUR-US certified?

Yes 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
CertiPUR-US Certified

Both Casper The One and Sleep Innovations Shiloh hold CertiPUR-US certification, ensuring the foam materials meet rigorous environmental and health standards.

Shows if foams meet CertiPUR-US safety standards.

Chemical-Free Fire Barrier

Does it use a chemical-free fire barrier?

Yes 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Chemical-Free Fire Barrier

Both mattresses feature a chemical-free fire barrier, making them safer and more eco-friendly choices for safety-conscious buyers.

Fire safety protection without chemical sprays.

Allergy-Friendly

Is it allergy-friendly?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

The mattress is allergy-friendly, designed to minimize allergens for improved health and comfort.

Mattress is suitable for people with allergies.

OEKO-TEX Certified

Is it OEKO-TEX certified?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
OEKO-TEX Certified

Sleep Innovations Shiloh is OEKO-TEX certified, whereas Casper The One is not, indicating Shiloh meets more stringent safety standards for textiles.

Ensures textiles are free from harmful substances.

Formaldehyde Free

Is the mattress formaldehyde free?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Formaldehyde Free

Sleep Innovations Shiloh is formaldehyde free while Casper The One is not, making Shiloh a better choice for customers avoiding formaldehyde exposure.

Indicates if product is free from formaldehyde chemicals.

Low VOC Emission

Does it have low VOC emission?

Yes 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
vs
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Low VOC Emission

Both Casper The One and Sleep Innovations Shiloh have low VOC emissions, promoting better indoor air quality for health-conscious consumers.

Ensures mattress has low volatile organic compound emissions.

Anti-Dust Mite Treatment

Does it have anti-dust mite treatment?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

The mattress includes an anti-dust mite treatment, which helps reduce allergens and improve health for sensitive users.

Treated to resist dust mites.

GREENGUARD Gold Certified

Is it GREENGUARD Gold certified?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Indicates compliance with low chemical emissions.

Asthma & Allergy Foundation Certification (AAFA)

Is it AAFA certified?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Confirms endorsement by AAFA for allergy safety.

Temperature & Climate 8

Breathable Cover

Does it have a breathable cover?

Yes 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
Casper The One

The breathable knit fabric cover promotes airflow, which helps with temperature regulation, keeping the mattress comfortable without the addition of cooling gel.

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

It has a breathable cover that promotes airflow, helping to keep the mattress cool and comfortable through the night.

Indicates if the outer cover allows airflow.

Moisture-Wicking Fabric

Does it use moisture-wicking fabric?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

The mattress features moisture-wicking fabric, which helps keep the sleeper dry and comfortable by drawing moisture away.

Ensures cover or material draws away sweat and moisture.

Cooling Gel Infusion

Does it have cooling gel infusion?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Indicates if cooling gel is infused in foam layers.

Phase Change Material

Does it use phase change materials?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Shows if mattress uses phase-change materials for temperature control.

Heat Dissipation Rating

What is the heat dissipation rating?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

65 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Good

Rates how well mattress disperses heat.

Climate Adaptability

Is it climate adaptable?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Indicates if mattress adapts to various climates.

Seasonal Use Design

Does it have a seasonal use design?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Mattress is designed with seasonal dual sides for hot and cold weather.

Airflow Channel Design

Does it feature airflow channels?

Yes 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Includes built-in airflow channels for ventilation.

Seating & Capacity 8

Maximum Weight Capacity

What is the maximum weight capacity?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

350 lbs 0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Maximum supported body weight.

Pet Friendly Design

Is it pet friendly?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Indicates if mattress surface resists pet scratches and fur.

Couple Friendly Design

Is it couple friendly?

Yes 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

This mattress is couple-friendly, accommodating two sleepers comfortably with minimal partner disturbance.

Indicates if mattress minimizes motion transfer and supports two sleepers.

Edge Sitting Comfort Rating

What is the edge sitting comfort rating?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

66 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes Good

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Edge sitting comfort is rated good, ensuring stable and comfortable seating on the mattress edges.

Rates how comfortable and stable the edge feels when sitting.

Bunk Bed Compatibility

Is it compatible with bunk beds?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

This mattress is compatible with bunk beds, signifying it meets necessary structural and safety standards.

Indicates if mattress is safe to use on bunk beds.

Heavy Sleeper Support

Does it support heavy sleepers?

Yes 1 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Indicates if the mattress provides extra support for heavier individuals.

Heavy sleeper support on Casper The One is a total game changer since Sleep Innovations Shiloh only supports up to 350 pounds which would be too limited for my needs.

See more

Seating Capacity

What is the seating capacity?

Who knows? 0 Votes Casper The One (Help us out by suggesting one!)

95 Sleep Innovations Shiloh 0 Votes 2 adults

Maximum number of people the mattress is designed to seat or sleep.

Child / Toddler Suitability

Is it suitable for children or toddlers?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Shows if the mattress is safe for children or toddlers.

Travel & Portability 7

Quick Expansion Time After Unboxing

What is the quick expansion time?

1 hrs 1 Votes
Casper The One
24 hrs 0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

The mattress fully expands within 24 hours after unboxing, ensuring it's ready for use quickly.

Time needed for mattress to reach full shape after opening.

The quick expansion time of just 1 hour on Casper The One makes it super convenient compared to the 24 hours needed for Sleep Innovations Shiloh to be fully ready.

See more

Vacuum-Sealed Packaging

Does it use vacuum-sealed packaging?

Yes 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Describes whether mattress is vacuum sealed for delivery.

Storage Bag

Is a storage bag included?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Shows if mattress comes with a bag for storage or moving.

Re-Rollable for Storage/Move

Can it be re-rolled for storage or moving?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Indicates if mattress can be re-rolled for easier moving or storage.

Roll Pack / Bed-in-Box Design

Is it a roll pack or bed-in-box design?

Yes 0 Votes Casper The One

Yes 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
Casper The One

The Casper One is vacuum-sealed and rolled into a compact box, making it easy to ship and unbox in your home. It expands to its full size within a few hours of unboxing.

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

It features a roll pack or bed-in-box design, making transportation and setup easier for consumers.

Indicates if the mattress is compressed and rolled into a box for shipping.

Easy Transport Handles

Does it have transport handles?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Shows if mattress includes sewn-in handles for moving.

Foldable Design

Is it foldable?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Indicates if mattress can be folded for storage or portability.

Technology & Smart Features 8

Sleep Tracking Integration

Does it integrate with sleep tracking?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Indicates if mattress integrates with sleep tracking systems.

Smart Sensor Connectivity

Does it connect with smart sensors?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Shows if mattress can connect with external smart sensors.

USB Charging Port

Does it have USB charging ports?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Shows if mattress includes built-in USB charging ports.

Wireless Control

Does it have wireless control?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Indicates if features can be controlled wirelessly.

App Connectivity

Does it have app connectivity?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Indicates if mattress has an app for customization or tracking.

Smart Home Compatibility

Is it smart home compatible?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Shows if mattress works with Alexa, Google Home, etc.

Integrated Heating or Cooling Control

Does it have integrated heating or cooling?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Indicates built-in heating or cooling control.

Anti-Snore Position Integration

Does it have anti-snore position integration?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Works with adjustable bases or sensors to reduce snoring.

Environmental & Sustainability 7

Recyclable Materials

Does it use recyclable materials?

Yes 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Casper The One
Casper The One

The mattress is designed with recyclable materials, making it a more eco-friendly option compared to many traditional mattresses.

Indicates if mattress materials can be recycled.

Take-Back / Recycling Program

Does it have a take-back program?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

This mattress does not participate in a take-back or recycling program.

Shows if brand offers a recycling or buy-back program.

Carbon Neutral Production

Is it carbon neutral in production?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Indicates if manufacturer offsets or eliminates carbon emissions.

Sustainable Sourcing

Is it sustainably sourced?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Shows if materials come from responsibly managed sources.

Biodegradable Components

Does it include biodegradable components?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Shows if components naturally break down after disposal.

Renewable Energy Manufacturing

Is it manufactured with renewable energy?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Indicates if renewable energy is used in production.

Plastic-Free Packaging

Does it use plastic-free packaging?

No 0 Votes Casper The One

No 0 Votes Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Confirms if packaging avoids single-use plastics.

Surveys

Because hot takes deserve votes.

Comfort Level

How comfortable is this mattress for everyday use?

Super comfy — Feels like sleeping on a cloud
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Pretty comfortable — Good for most sleep positions
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Decent comfort — Works for short naps
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
A bit too firm — Not very cozy
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Hard and uncomfortable — Feels stiff all night
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Durability

How long does this mattress last before showing wear and tear?

Extremely durable — Over 12 years
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Long lasting — 9 to 12 years
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Good durability — 6 to 8 years
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Moderate lifespan — 3 to 5 years
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Very short lifespan — Less than 3 years
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Firmness

How firm does this mattress feel when lying down?

Extra firm — Very rigid and supportive
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Firm — Strong support with little sink
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Medium — Balanced support and softness
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Soft — Gently cushioned
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Ultra soft — Sinks in deeply
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Motion Isolation

How well does this mattress reduce movement transfer at night?

Excellent — Barely feel any motion
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Good — Only strong shifts are felt
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Decent — Minor movements are felt
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Somewhat poor — Frequent disturbance
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Very poor — Every movement is noticeable
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Thickness

How thick is this mattress in height?

Extra thick — Over 15 inches
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Thick — 13 to 15 inches
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Medium — 10 to 12 inches
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Thin — 6 to 9 inches
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Very thin — Less than 6 inches
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Temperature Regulation

How well does this mattress stay cool at night?

Very cool — Always stays fresh
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Cool — Feels comfortable most nights
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Average — Neutral temperature
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Somewhat warm — Gets a little stuffy
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Very hot — Traps a lot of heat
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Ease of Setup

How easy was it to set up this mattress at home?

Super simple — Done in no time
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Pretty easy — Quick setup without stress
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Manageable — Took some effort but fine
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
A bit difficult — Needed extra help
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
A total hassle — Took forever to set up
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Design Appeal

How attractive does this mattress look in a bedroom?

Beautiful design — Looks high-end
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Stylish — Adds to the room look
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Decent — Matches most rooms
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Okay — Nothing special
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Plain and boring — Looks cheap
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Pricing

How would you rate the price of this mattress?

Great value for money
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Pretty good price
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Fair deal
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Kinda pricey
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Crazy expensive
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Edge Support Strength

How sturdy are the edges of this mattress when sitting or lying near the side?

Excellent edge strength — No sinking at all
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Strong edge support — Slight compression only
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Moderate edge support — Noticeable sinking
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Weak edge support — Feels unstable at sides
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Very weak — Collapses when sitting on edge
0 Votes
Casper The One
0 Votes
Sleep Innovations Shiloh

Guides 1

Files 1

Your Casper The One Assistance Guide

shopify.com
shopify.com

Reviews 0

The good, the bad, and the brutally honest.

Average Rating

Casper
Casper
Casper The One
Casper The One
0 / 5 0 Reviews
Sleep Innovations
Sleep Innovations
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
0 / 5 0 Reviews

Discussions 0

Thoughts, takes, and hot debates.

Awards 7

Only the best made it here.

Collections 0

Treasures You’ve picked. No fluff, all fun.

More Mattresses 0

Unlock more awesome finds.

Other Casper Mattresses 16

Other Sleep Innovations Mattresses 6

Casper The One
Casper
Casper
Casper The One
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
Sleep Innovations
Sleep Innovations
Sleep Innovations Shiloh
vs